There’s a moment in some relationships that leaves you sitting there thinking, wait… did that really just happen?

Maybe it’s later that night and you’re on the couch replaying something from earlier. At dinner, in front of a few friends, someone made a comment about you. It was the kind of remark that gets a quick laugh and then everyone suddenly becomes very interested in their food.

Something like, “Well… we all know she can be a little dramatic.”

You laugh too, mostly because that’s the socially acceptable thing to do when a room full of people just looked at you.

The conversation moves on. Dessert happens. Everyone goes home.

But the comment sticks with you. So later that night you bring it up. Not aggressively. Not like you’re launching a full investigation. Just a simple, “Hey… that comment earlier felt a little rough.”

And that’s when the conversation flips.

“I never said that.”

Now you’re confused.

“Yes, you did. At dinner.”

“No I didn’t. You’re remembering it wrong.”

Then the follow-ups start.

“You’re always twisting things people say.”
“You’re imagining things again.”
“You’re way too sensitive about stuff like this.”

Now somehow the conversation isn’t about the comment anymore.

You start explaining the moment. Who was there. What was said. The tone. The timing. The way the table got quiet right after it happened. Before long you’re giving a full breakdown of a ten-second comment like you’re presenting evidence in a courtroom that nobody else agreed to attend.

Meanwhile the other person has already moved on with their evening. And you’re sitting there wondering whether the moment actually happened the way you remember it.

That’s gaslighting.

Not disagreement. Not “we heard it differently.”

Gaslighting is when someone slowly shifts the conversation from what happened to whether your perception can be trusted.

Your Brain Behind It

Your brain is wired to notice social tension quickly. Tone shifts, facial expressions, awkward pauses, the energy in a room changing after someone says something uncomfortable. Your nervous system catches those signals before your logical brain has time to neatly explain them.

So when something feels off, there’s usually a reason your brain noticed it.

The problem is that when someone says “you’re imagining it” or “you’re overthinking it,” your brain suddenly has two competing messages. One part of you is saying something about that moment didn’t sit right. The other part is now being told nothing happened.

That’s why people start explaining. Your brain is trying to resolve the mismatch.

Unfortunately, the more you explain the moment, the more the conversation quietly shifts away from the comment and toward your reaction.

And that’s exactly how the original moment disappears.

The ShiFt

When someone tries to shut down the conversation with “you’re overthinking it,” the instinct is to defend your perception.

Ironically, that’s the trap.

The more you explain, the easier it is for the conversation to become about your reaction instead of the original comment.

A better move is to keep your response short.

If someone says, “You’re overthinking it,” you can say something like, “Maybe. It still bothered me.” Then stop there. No speech. No play-by-play of the dinner conversation.

Another move that works well is bringing the focus back to the comment itself. If someone says you took it the wrong way, try asking, “Okay… then what did you mean by it?”

That small shift changes the dynamic of the conversation and holds them accountable for what they said - even if they won't take accountability for it. Instead of defending your reaction, you’re calmly putting the attention back on the comment that started it.

Because the real problem with gaslighting isn’t the comment. It’s the slow erosion of trust in your own instincts.

Your Turn

What phrase do you hear most when someone is trying to dismiss what you’re saying?

“You’re overthinking it”?
“You took that the wrong way”?
Something else?

Hit reply and tell me. I read every response.

I have a feeling there are some very creative versions out there.

Speaker & Author
Communication Expert

​​​​